Music-story's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[(-Fission-)]

Review

Hi Ian,

The beginning of your song started great. Unfortunately, I began to quickly notice the dissonance. I'm not a fan of dissonance....but others are so umm. Well, I think if you play in one key you should keep the sharps/flats consistent through the whole song except for maybe a transition.

I definitely felt the space feel in this song. Good job on your reverb, panning, and delay. The drums seem well EQed.

45 seconds in I didn't really like that bass instrument. It really made things sound out of tune when that lead instrument came back in.

1:31 not too sure if that funky instrument was the best choice. Maybe you should have cut down the high frequencies a bit to get that nice low sound.

2:15 I noticed two notes with that new instrument. I think you should have used that instrument more in this song.

I guess this will fit for your CD theme. This was a tough song to review for me. Dissonance is a love it or hate it so my review might be a bit biased. I'll still give you the 5/5 and 9/10 review.

Bye for now

XTriNovaX responds:

Everything is on the same key, I don't know what your talking about :P.

Thats good. Its supposed to do that.

That bass had been going on sense the begining of the song, and honestly I cant hear the out of tune.

Agree with how the instrument is to funky. But the backing kinda makes up for it.

That was actually a glitch :P but sense it sounded good, i didn't care.

Thanks for the review!

[(-Mars-)]

Review

Hi Ian,

This must be some really high quality song. 6.4mb for less than a 3 minute song. Personally, as long as I can hear all the instruments and there is no clipping, I find the mastering and mixing to be just fine. I'm wondering how you got "Mars" from this song.

Umm, so I'm not the best person to review DnB music. Not a big fan of it. Anyway....

I like that alien theme sound to start the song. The amount of reverb seems just about right.

Well I guess drums is like 50% of the criteria for what makes good DnB music. I'm looking for some unique drum patterns, but I notice the standard drum beat. At least it doesn't sound like that familiar fruity loop dnb pattern tons of the unexperienced DnB musicians use. Your snare drum rolls seem to be in the right place at the right time.

You like to use a lot of those funky instruments. I guess it matches your mood your going for in your CD. I'm not sure if that's what other DnB artists on here prefer. (This doesn't refer to me since I'm not a DNB artist) I don't mind the bass, but I think the bass composition needs more variety. For example, at 56 seconds in you keep that same bass pattern going on for the rest of the song. At least, some automation changes might have added some diversity. I do have to give you kudos for the darker lower bass instrument. It has a simple pattern that is kinda give me dance vibes.

Some alien like fx sounds would have helped. Not sure if DnB is technically allowed to use anything else besides drums and bass.....but fx would make this song sound better.

Lastly, kudos on the kick pattern to end your song. Lots of musicians continually place the kicks in the most obvious places.

Here is a 5/5 vote and 9/10 review. I think since your CD is going to be ambient based, you should not put other genre of songs in the CD.

Bye for now

XTriNovaX responds:

Thanks for the review! I will more in-depth counter review later.
(I honestly dont have the time to do a counter review, sorry D:)

[Far Away (NB)]

Review

Hi Nosebleed,

This one actually sounds different from the other house songs on NG. I give you kudos for the originality. Here is my review.

Yes, the typical house kick is nice though I did think the solo kicks were a bit too long.
15 seconds in and I love what you did with your umm percussion? Nice job. I also like the buildup happening to 1:00 minute.

Unfortunately at 1:00 I was expecting for the climax and didn't get it. Sounds more like ambient here. Pretty pads though.

2:00 I like what you did with your sidechaining. I like those kicks and percussion. The only issue is that you probably compressed the kicks way too much muffling out the lead instrument. (Maybe you skipped the whole sidechaining process and found a kick that already has a sidechaining effect...I don't know....I'm assuming you did sidechain intentionally though)

3:00 the lead instrument seems to be playing too much dissonance. It isn't in tune. Fortunately it seems to fit better at 3:30 This is the best part of your song.

4:00 sounds pretty nice. I was expecting something big to come out of it, but well the song just ended.

So I think you might need some better EQing on the dirty instruments. The song kinda starts slow but it gets going halfway through. House is fun to make. Glad you had fun making this. 5/5 and 9/10 review.

Bye for now

DJ-NOSEBLEED responds:

I sidechained intentionally.
Yea i dont submit really well mixed songs/ good songs to ng really.

[More Than Words (Lira's V]

How the, NG is messed up

Hi Lira,

I never even heard about you on NG. When your definitely a underdog here. This song is much better than a lot of other songs on NG. However, I still notice some problems. I notice both you and pulstate made this so my criticisms will be to the both of you. I won't bother with the good things since you already got some good reviews from your past reviews talking about them.

Fixings:
1) You got a good voice...I think it might need more reverb to it to make your voice sound like an angel. Plus I can't really tell what your even saying in some parts of the song. :) I think you need to sing louder or need to get rid of some instruments or reverb on the instruments.
2) 2:00 the pads seem to not be eq as tight as I would have liked. There is some fuzzing going on in the background and the lower frequencies seem to be too intense. This is particularly noticeable at 2:45.
3) There doesn't seem to be enough vocals. Need to hear more of your voice.
4) Those drums with the high frequency cymbals going on make the song sound a bit messy.
5) 5:48 ouch. That hurt my ears. Some weird really high frequency spike in an instrument or your voice at that time. Fortunately that is very short lived.
6) 6:29 the EQ needs fixing again on those pads. This song is really repetitive too.

Umm, I stopped at like 7 minutes. I was hearing the same stuff again. I'll just be saying the same thing again. Anyway, its tough to come by confident singers on NG. Great job pulstae and yourself in producing this mix. 5/5 and 9/10 review.

Liralei responds:

This was an amateur sound engineering job done over Pulstate's original track only at 96 kbps, so the quality isn't fantastic.
As for the repetitiveness...well, such is the structure of trance. The beginning and ending 1:30 are meant to be fairly superfluous, for proper mixing.

I appreciate the feedback, and thanks for the support. :)

[A New Coming (Demo)]

Review

Hi Druid,

You don't have to review another song of mine. I'm actually returning you the favour. I'm kinda glad you submitted this song because I'm a terrible reviewer of hip hop music. I'm still kinda bad in reviewing classical music, but not as bad. :) Here goes

The beginning sounds really epic like a battle is about to start in China. Those drums from the timpani? are amazing. 35 seconds I love how you change the mood of the song. Diversity factor is good here. The other good point is that you don't make some completely different genre that has no relevance to your 1st theme. The marching drums are still there. I still see a war....just the happier part of the war when its all finished. Maybe its just me but when the song loops it kinda gives you chill. Kinda makes me imagine that there is peace and then all of a sudden some dark evil force (pardon the cheesy adjectives) just takes over.

Now, I listened to many other classical songs on NG and am making a comparison to yours. I have heard better war like classical songs on NG so I'll give you a 9/10. However, your song is still good. The instruments sounds good. What program do you use to make classical instruments? My music program has awful classical instruments and I'm too lazy to modify them.

Okay so again 5/5 and 9/10 review.

Bye for now

Druids-Warcry responds:

Thank you for your review sir! Really lot of critical feed back that was very much needed!

The program I used was FL8 not a lot of effects going on here, I'm using the Orchestral Kit from Edirol. Constierting this is my first classical piece of music I have made and your rating it with the others must mean I'm doing something right! But this was a snippet of what is to come! I really do hope to make it about 15 mins long

[(-Polarity-)]

Review

Hi Ian,

Are you still making your cd? Is this an experimental? Its a very strange tune. Some hardstyle, dnb, umm maybe dance, and yeah you do add a new perspective with music. Your right about the drums not really fitting in this song. Oh well, here is what I thought.

Good:
1) Let the insanity begin at 52 seconds. I like how you gradually brought in a new layer of instrument to keep changing things up.
2) 1:16 I like your instrumental pattern. However I think the instrument needs some revision. (Umm the latter point should go in the "hmm" section.
3) I like your kicks. They are very hard. Almost reminds me of jumpstyle music.
4) Okay so one highlight about your drum pattern is at 2:26. I love how you panned and delayed the cymbals and kick. Nice idea

Hmm:
1) At the very beginning of the song the bass was way too subbed. It doesn't actually sound like a note but some low sounding dirty noise. May need an eq adjustment.

2) Instrument at 9 seconds that fades in lacks dynamics. It might require some tighter control on the imaging. Not sure what your music program calls it.

10/10 on the originality. However, the tune does seem a bit whacked. I guess that's miscellaneous music for you. This is not something I'd listen to on the radio, but once in a while listening to the strangest forms of music is great. Again, wish you luck on your CD and here is your 5/5 and 9/10 review.

Bye for now

XTriNovaX responds:

Ya, im stilling working on my cd, its just shelved at the moment. I got bored and started doing this, and i actually it finished so i uploaded it. I'm currently working on a jump styleish DnB song.

To #3, multiband compressors are your friend.
To #4, Thats a flanger, gate, and like you said, a delay. Its fun to do.

To #1 Hmm, Its supposed to sound like a bass hit, so in a way its a sub sub bass hit.

I agree with the song not really fitting with its self, but it is experimental.

Thanks for the review!
-TriNova

[]a[> Outsider]

Review

Hi Alert,

Umm, not sure how the past reviewer got the image of the old lady. Interesting idea though. Here is what I thought:

Good:
1) The piano sounds simply like a piano. The composition is interesting so kudos on the melody.
2) I like the pads....or are those strings? Anyway, its what brings the emotion to this song.
3) I'm intrigued by the drum patterns you used. Never heard a pattern like that before.
4) 3:00 lots of stuff is going on. I like busy music. It shows someone who knows how to make melodies match together.

Hmm:
1) I'm not too fond of the bass. Sounds a bit too funky to fit with this emotional song of yours. Maybe use a bass (not the synthesized bass but a real bass sound) instead of this farting like sound. :)
2) I think you might have too many high frequency sounds at 1:49. I can hear them all, but one of the instrument's makes some screeching sound. That might have caused the "too much high frequency" feeling.
3) I'm not a fan of that rising fx sound. Rave sounds in this kind of song is quite odd. Maybe cymbal roll could have been better.

Overall, I like the mood of this song. This is a song style that I hardly hear on NG which is quite refreshing. I did sense a bit of repetitiveness with your piano melody. Other tthen what I said already, I think that this song is long enough as it is. Keep up the good work with the layering of instruments. I can see future songs by you to be melodically complex making you stand out from guys who don't know how to play the piano. 5/5 and 9/10 review.

Bye for now

alertG responds:

thanks for the detailed review. i did notice some of the things that you had mentioned, but some of the other points were opinions that made me listen back on the song more intently. I did start with the beginning piano beat, but yeah i did notice the repetativeness. The problem I had was taking out the piano would make it feel like something is missing. However, maybe I can change the "high frequency" sounds to mix better and take out the piano. I might change it up a little.

In my opinion I like the fading in synth, but thanks for all of your feedback!

[Calmly Spun]

Review

Hi IO,

I never actually got that many song reviews in such a short time so time to catch up on reviewing back.

Another short one by me. You seem to produce really short songs limiting my criticisms.

So, you really have a interest to making the weird mystery type of music. Where does your inspiration come from? There is one sound I enjoyed. It's that fuzzy sound. I thought the pad was quite mellow yet strangely evil. As for the drums, I didn't mind them much. Didn't interfere with the mood of this loop. I'm interested in what kind of full length song you can make.

5/5 and 9/10 review.

Bye for now

InvisibleObserver responds:

Soon we'll have been through all of each others work.

I've been posting a few shorter loops that may be helpful to NG users, as for full length, I have a couple up, but they simply take much longer to make, and even longer for me to be comfortable with calling them complete, and I'm trying to avoid putting up things that aren't near completion.

Yes I do have an interest in an odd 'style' of music, I'm not a big fan of the mainstream style of sounds (Typically house = yucky, as an example).

Inspiration comes from lots of little oddities, I remember a garbage truck making an odd sound and I tried to recreate it. Other times though I'll just sit down and see what I can come up with, without an end goal in mind.